SAVANT is a weekly comics magazine with an activist bent, aimed at readers, retailers, and professionals of all stripes interested in the comics industry. We're here to make things better.

Welcome to the front lines.

 

 

REVIEWS // 7.11.02


Battle of the PlanetsThe Girly ComicMy Monkey's Name Is Jennifer
Spider-Man's Tangled Web
Stormwatch: Team AchillesVertigo POP! TokyoXXXLiveNudeGirls

BATTLE OF THE PLANETS #1
Munier Sharrieff/Wilson Tortosa/UDON

US $2.95
Image/Top Cow

Oh boy….

OK, let’s just start with the positives I could find:

1) It’s about a group of Blue Falcon-looking teenagers that fight giant robots and kick much ass.

2) Wilson Tortosa’s art is damn pretty to look at and the Shane Law of UDON makes with the shiny colors.

3) They kept their old-school 70’s fashions. Mark and Jason kept their wicked-neato Dirk Diggler haircuts, and it looks like the old cartoon.

4) The president’s a woman—You go, girlfriend!

“Before Power Rangers, Ninja Turtles, or Pokemon, there was…BATTLE OF THE PLANETS,” reads the advertisement. That’s a major part of the problem with this comic. Pokemon, Ninja Turtles, and Power Rangers were for KIDS. Battle of the Planets would be a great comic for kids, but let’s face it. No kid’s ever going to get his hands on this comic, because it’s geared toward Generation X nostalgia. It even makes reference to Keeyop’s porn stash. I don’t remember that in the cartoon, and I watched that cartoon every Saturday like a retard.

Since the story isn’t over, I’m not going to make any judgments on the plot. The plot, actually looks to be headed somewhere. But the groan-inducing expository captions and hackneyed dialogue reminds you of watching one of those old cartoons. The conversations in this comic have the feel of G.I. JOE, or THUNDERCATS, or any one of those cheesy-ass kids cartoons. Except….

Except….

EXCEPT THIS COMIC WASN’T MADE FOR KIDS!

“Stow it, fat-boy,” says Jason. “At least I get off on chicks instead of food….”

Oooh…BURN! Only a kid would find something like that to be witty, but you know damn well that this is marketed towards those same twenty-somethings that bought TRANSFORMERS and G.I. JOE, and will be first in line for a MASK or DINOSAUCERS revival. What kind of fucking nerds are you people? In the words of a very wise man, “Honk, you motherfuckers! HONK!”

If you think comics are better than sex, then by all means, go and waste your money on this. I, for one, am going to wait for the right time to sell this back. That’s right. This comic is so bad, speculation seems like a more appealing option.

I really wanted to give this comic a chance. I really did. But fuck nostalgia in the ass, man. It’s like Thomas Wolfe said, “You can’t go home again.” This sucks, and it’s never going to be as great as you remember it being. But because I’m a hypocrite, I’m going to tell you to spend your money on the latest ASTRO BOY trade instead.

(Jeff Chon)

* * *

THE GIRLY COMIC #1
Julian Eales/Steve Ince ('Domestic Dispute')

Andy Grant/Kelvin Green/Liam Creighton/Jay Eales ('The Wait')
Arthur Goodman ('The Fall of Dagon'rah')
Paul Grimes/Emma Segar ('Urban Shaman')
Lee Kennedy ('My Life as a Goddess' and 'Stupid Songs In My Head All Day')
Terry Wiley ('Surreal School Stories')
Bear ('I Want My Own Gimp!')
David Goodman ('Creative Differences')
Paul Perry and PeeT! ('Furlough')
Barry Williams and Paul Harrison ('My Poison Pen Pal!')
Jay Eales ('Spon')
Selina Lock and Graeme Neil Reid ('Kiss Ability')

£1.50
Factor Fiction


That sound you can hear, like running feet? That's all the people who wrote this off the second they read the title.

They're wrong. Their loss.

THE GIRLY COMIC was one of the undisputed stars of the small press section at Bristol 2002 and it's easy to see why. With a fantastic cover by Reid, good production values and a huge amount of material for a low price, there's a lot to recommend this straight away.

However, that's not all there is to it. As well as being a remarkably varied and intelligent anthology, THE GIRLY COMIC was created with three specific aims in mind. Effectively, it had a mission statement and one which editor Selina Lock reprints at the end of the issue. Condensed, it looks like this.

1)Try to attract female readers.
2)Attract female creators but not to the exclusion of the male.
3)Sell more than five copies.

The mission statement is almost worth the price of admission by itself, as it manages to be both entertaining and absolutely direct. Lock and Co. defined their goals, worked out what needed to be done and Did It.

Not only that but they did it supremely well. Of the thirteen stories in this issue not one can safely be called weak. Some grabbed me more than others, but the collection is of such a high quality and such variety that there’s simply no weak material here.

However, there are several standouts. “The Fall of Dagon’rah” is a well observed and very funny piece about the worst aspects of roleplaying, whilst “I Want My Own Gimp!” combines gentle, cartoony artwork with some well observed dialogue and an excellent punchline. Similarly, Lee Kennedy’s illustrated monologues are hugely entertaining and at times poignant, combining cartoony art with nostalgia and a hint of sadness. The nearest I can get to describing it is somewhere between the domestic material in STRANGERS IN PARADISE and Harvey Pekar’s AMERICAN SPLENDOR.

Other standouts include Lock and Reid’s short but well-observed “Kiss Ability” and my personal favorite, “The Wait”. The story of a girl waiting for her boyfriend and the fears that begin to plague her, it’s an utterly genuine, utterly unpretentious slice of life. There’s no major plot development, no stunning conclusion, just a well-told story with genuine emotional impact. The final page alone justifies the cover price.

All in all, THE GIRLY COMIC is a supremely confident, assured debut. Intelligent, funny, moving and varied this is one of the best comics I’ve read this year. It really is that good.

(Al Stuart)

* * *

MY MONKEY’S NAME IS JENNIFER #3
Ken Knudtsen

US $2.95
Slave Labor Graphics

This is the start of a new storyline, which means that you can jump on here and not feel like you’re missing anything.

On the other hand, it’s not like this book is overwhelmingly complex. There’s a monkey. His name is Jennifer. He hates humans and want to eat them. He does not talk aloud, but he does narrate the story.

This storyline features pirates.

If, by this point in the review, you’ve said “Monkeys! Great!” or “Pirates! Cool!” or even just “Arrrr!”, this book is probably for you.

If you’re wondering how the hell all of these things fit together and how it can possible make logical sense, you can probably safely pass on the whole thing and skip on to the next book on your list.

You know, I don’t even know why I’m writing this out. It’s funny, it’s got a monkey, it’s got pirates. Nothing else really needs to be said.

(Matt Terl)

* * *

SPIDER-MAN’S TANGLED WEB #1
Paul Pope
US $2.95
Marvel Comics

I love this series because I get my Spider-Man fix without feeling guilty about reading Spider-Man. Great creators get their chance to tell great stories. But why should I feel guilty? It’s freakin’ Spider-Man, for God’s sake. If you don’t like Spider-Man, then I hoped you were working last Independence Day, you filthy Pinkos.

This installment, Paul Pope tells the story of a young girl who loves Spider-Man without the guilt most of us feel about loving the web-slinger. Her dad hates Spider-Man and rips her Spidey posters off the wall. Kind of reminds me of the time my dad tore down my Jason Bateman posters. Sniff…Bastard!

The best Tangled Web stories are the ones where Spider-Man is in the periphery, and Pope focuses on the young girl, showing us her teenybopper-like devotion to Spider-Man (Let’s face it, Spider-Man’s a pop star through and through) and the excitement she feels every time he’s mentioned on the news. The fact the news of the Stag Beetle’s rampage excites her is very charming, as we’ve all done this every time Spider-Man’s faced a new villain… Yes you have, so shut your punk-ass mouth and stop lying.

It’s a quiet minimalist piece, as opposed to the usual over-wrought superhero comics we’re used to, and it’s a nice change of pace. The girl’s facial expressions tell most of the story, and Pope uses this to great effect. We’ve seen the “kid with the Spidey scrapbook” motif before, but Pope keeps it entertaining with a goofy-named Ditko-era style villain named the Stag Beetle (“Cretins! Worms! No one is safe from my fury!”). I enjoyed everything from the forshadowing in the beginning to the heartbreaking conclusion.

Tangled Web is a cool series because it’s like a tribute album to your favorite band, and you’re always wondering how each artist is going to cover their chosen song. If you still have a yen for Spider-Man, this is the series worth reading, and I hope Marvel continues giving us interesting takes from interesting creators. COUGH—Dave Lapham—COUGH—Make it happen, you bastards.

(Jeff Chon)

* * *

STORMWATCH: TEAM ACHILLES #1
Micah Ian Wright
/Whilce Portacio/Scott Williams

US $2.95
DC/Wildstorm/Eye of the Storm

I almost didn’t buy this book. Everyone kept mentioning Tom Clancy as part of the high concept, and I hate Tom Clancy. And I haven’t liked Whilce Portacio’s art since he drew Punisher way the hell back in the eighties, when I was young and ignorant about such things. And I find these attempts by superhero publishers to publish superhero books but claim that they’re NOT, in fact, superhero books kind of amusing and kind of depressing.

But writer Micah Ian Wright has shown a sharp sense of humor over on the Warren Ellis Forum with his modified propaganda posters , and he also seemed really proud of the book. Plus, he’s worked on Nickelodeon’s Invader Zim, so I figured what the hell, and I wound up happy I had.

There was a moment, though, where I wasn’t so sure. The first image in the book is of a woman apparently jogging in a midriff-baring T-shirt and cut-off bootie shorts open at the waist, with sick, over-defined hyper-nipples poking through the short. Given the odd “jogging” pose she’s in, she looks like a Hooter’s waitress with an invisible tray.

NOT an ausipicious beginning at all.

The rest of the issue picks up nicely, though, especially if you can look past the art.

This book moves along like a big action movie, but one of the smarter ones -- say, the original Die Hard. Lots of snappy dialogue, lots of things blowing up, and characters who are really nothing but manliness.

So it’s good, if you like that sort of thing. Which I do. But there’s really not much more in this first issue, and Portacio’s art, despite being the strongest he’s done in ages, is still not the easiest to follow.

Fun stuff, for what it is, and highly recommended if you’re in the right mood.

(Matt Terl)

* * *

VERTIGO POP! TOKYO #1
Jonathan Vankin/Seth Fisher

US $2.95
DC/Vertigo

People in Japan apparently have no noses. I had no idea.

This is a very cool book, with some gorgeous (albeit noseless) artwork and a promising premise.  The first issue wasn’t as good as I was hoping for, but it is well worth reading, and will probably read best if it is ever collected into a trade paperback.

There’s an element of a fish-out-of-water story here, an American geek who’s up and moved himself to Japan. But writer Jonathan Vankin makes the somewhat questionable decision not to tell the entire story through his point of view, and to only use his narration while he’s “onscreen”. Which allows for the story to range with a bit more freedom, but also makes some of the non-narrated scenes more confusing than they might otherwise have been.

Aside from that quibble, though, this is a solid first issue. Like just about everyone else, it sometimes seems, I find contemporary Japan fascinating, so it’s nice to see it being tackled in comic book form. And Seth Fisher’s smooth, detailed (except for noses) art and Chris Chuckry’s pastel colors are perfect for it.

In fact, with this, Grant Morrison’s The Filth, and the forthcoming books under the Vertigo Pop! banner, Vertigo as a line is really starting to feel cutting-edge and relevant again, with Fables, Lucifer, and Midnight, Mass as strong representatives of the more “traditional” Vertigo style.

And well past time, too.

(Matt Terl)

* * *

XXXLIVENUDEGIRLS #1
Laurenn Mcubbin/Nikki Coffman
US $2.95
Penny Dreadful Press
 
It’s fashionable to like this book at the moment. It’s being talked about, being promoted, is shortly to become available through artbomb.net and is basically being talked up in a lot of the places that count. This can only be a good thing. It’s a well written, visually fascinating book that does nothing that anything else being published does half as well. It’s interesting, it’s different and it’s actually got some genuine artistic worth.

The problem is, that may not be enough for some people. For others, it may be an active turnoff.

Those people are wrong. This book IS important and IS worth your time.

XXXLIVENUDEGIRLS is a short read, but an utterly haunting one. There’s no overall story here, rather a collection. All are bleary-eyed, Carver-esque stories, taking a snapshot of different women at different stages in their lives. In ‘Drugs’ one struggles to remember why she took the drugs that have taken her memory whilst ‘Sex’ sees another woman faced with an ex-lover in the most mundane of places. Finally, ‘Rage’ sees a third engaged in a fight which is as much a contest of endurance as it is one of anger. All are bleak, desolate pieces which come and go with tremendous speed.

They’re also all fantastic examples of graphic storytelling. The artwork is taken from photographs, twisted and retouched through numerous filters and cut and pastes. All in shades of grey, it gives the world of XXXLIVENUDEGIRLS a vaguely clammy, washed out feel that only serves to heighten the atmosphere.

This is not normal comics and that’s the best recommendation possible. Mccubbin and Cofffman have created something which is bleak without ever being maudlin and artistic without ever being pretentious. It’s not an easy read, but it’s one which is quite unlike anything else on the market. Intelligent, unusual and haunting, this is a tremendous debut.

In short, this book IS important, and is deserving not only of the attention it’s been getting, but of your own. Read it.

(Al Stuart)

Discuss this column on the SAVANT forum .