Top 10 Best Drugstore Liquid Eyeliners of 2019 – Reviews

Drugstore liquid eyeliners are some of the most effective products for creating sharp lines on a budget. In the past, these cosmetic products haven’t received the credit they deserve. These products not only rival expensive designer eyeliners in terms of ease-of-use but often rival them in terms of quality. Sure, there are some dollar-store brands which are inferior in quality, but there’s also a lot of drugstore budget brands that are actually better than their name-brand counterparts.

That’s why we’ve decided to dig into the issue and see which brands are actually the best ones available. We’ve done our research and have come up with the brands that we feel are not only economical but also deliver quality. Anyone looking for a good quality liquid eyeliner is probably going to want to check out the following top ten drugstore liquid eyeliners that we’ve found.

Best Drugstore Liquid Eyeliners – Top List

10Docolor Liquid Eyeliner Pen

buy from amazon

This product is designed to be completely waterproof, which makes it suitable for just about any occasion. It provides up to 12-hours of wear and is hypoallergenic, so it’s suitable to be used by both contact lens wearers and individuals with sensitive eyes. This smudge-proof product is also really easy-to-use and is small enough to be placed into just about any handbag. And the results it provides are pretty dramatic. It produces bold lines that go on evenly, dries quickly and is easy to shape into the wearer’s desired result. It’s also easy to clean up and remove when the day is over.

9e.l.f. Precision Liquid Eyeliner

buy from amazon

This is not only one of the most inexpensive eyeliners of any type, either liquid or gel, but what most people don’t realize is that it’s also a high-quality one as well. When it’s applied, it produces a nice, bold black color that can last up to 12-hours long. That’s long enough for it to last all day long and well into the evening. This product also features an easy-to-use tapered brush design that allows it to go on nice and smoothly. Its dark pigment glides on and allows the wearer to craft the precise, custom lines they need to accentuate their own personal style.

8L’Oreal Paris Lineur Intense Brush Tip

buy from amazon

Specifically designed for glam applications, this eyeliner is designed to deliver excellent results quickly and easily. It has a brush-tip applicator that gives users the precise control they need when creating lines. Its brush’s tapered edge also allow lines to be slick and to have a professional look to them. And since this product is available in black, brown or carbon black, the user can pick just the right one that fits in with their style. It’s a product that delivers 8-hours of wear and is completely smudge-proof, so it can be worn any time of the day or night.

7Palladio Pigmented Eyeliner

buy from amazon

With an ultra-fine tip that allows it to be applied smoothly, this eyeliner has many of the features that people look for when they purchase a drugstore liquid eyeliner. It can be used to not only create big, bold lines but can also be used to create subtle lines as needed by the user. It goes on without smudging and lasts all day long, This product is also made with paraben-free ingredients and is always cruelty-free. All of which makes this product one that’s suitable for not the average user but is also probably suitable enough to be used by professional makeup artists.

6Prestige Black Eyeliner

buy from amazon

When most people select an eyeliner, they’re happy with one that will go on smoothly, doesn’t smudge, and provides 12-hour protection. And this product is capable of delivering all three of these things. However, it just doesn’t stop there it also provides other benefits that most people will find useful. For example, it dermatologically-tested, so it’s safe for contact wearers or those with sensitivities. It’s also free of all gluten and gluten derivatives. But where it really shines is the ability to create dramatic and extremely sharp lines that get noticed and will help the wearer get noticed and help make them the star of the show.

5Rimmel Exaggerate Felt Tip Liner

buy from amazon

This product combines the ease and versatility of a liquid liner with the precision and control of a felt tip liner. The result is a product that goes on smoothly and can be used to create incredibly precise lines. It doesn’t matter if the wearer is trying for a smokey eye or going for a cat eye, this liner is always ready to deliver. And although it isn’t waterproof, it is smudge resistant and will stay where it’s supposed to stay during just about any occasion. It can also be used to craft both subtle and bold lines. The best thing about this liner, however, is probably its price. It’s one of the more inexpensive liners currently available.

4Revlon ColorStay Skinny Liquid Eyeliner

buy from amazon

This Revlon Liner is designed with one purpose in mind, and that’s to give the wearer a skinny, and well-defined line that highlights their makeup. This liner has a 0.1mm applicator that allows for super thin lines to be applied with absolute precision. And once applied this product goes on without smearing or smudging. This allows this liner to be worn with the utmost confidence. Other features worth mentioning about this product is that it’s ophthalmologist-tested for safety, and can be worn by even users with sensitive skin. Overall, it’s a product that ‘s perfect for anyone who wants crisp, clean lines.

3Milani Eye Tech Extreme Liner

buy from amazon

Expensive eyeliners seem to have the uncanny ability to go on without feathering. Fortunately, so does this particular brand, even though it only costs a fraction of the price of those other designer eyeliners. This liner can often be applied in just one stroke and deliver crisp bold lines that will make just about anyone take notice. That’s because it has a fine felt-tip point that gives the user the precision and control they need. Once it’s applied, it doesn’t budge either, and it should last most people all day long. Another key feature about this product is that it’s not very shiny, so it can be worn for just about any occasion.

2NYX Professional Epic Liner

buy from amazon

Sometimes professional results have to be achieved, even when using a budget eyeliner. Fortunately, this product is not only inexpensive, but it can also deliver some truly astounding results. It’s a black liner that’s waterproof, has a nice matte finish and comes with a precision brush tip. These three features allow it to do fine lines, smokey eyes, cat eyes and just about anything else that can be done with an eyeliner. It goes on smoothly, doesn’t smudge and provides reliable results each and every time. It’s a brand that’s sure to impress just about anyone willing to give it a chance.

1Absolute New York NANO Liner

buy from amazon

This liner is for anyone who not only needs a smear-proof liner but also one that delivers the precision they expect. This product is manufactured in a way that allows it to be applied to the eye in ultra-fine lines that can be built upon each other. This means that the wearer can go with a simple, thin line or can use this product for more dramatic eye effects. This liner provides a nice matte black color and is formulated so that it doesn’t contain fragrances or paraben. The best feature about this product, however, is that it stays put once it’s been applied and doesn’t smudge.

Can’t Find What You’re Looking For? Check these suggestions:

Using an Eyeliner With Confidence

It’s not always easy to buy an eyeliner that works the way it’s supposed to work. There seem to be about a million different brands out there, and all of them claim to be the best. Worse than that, however, is the fact that women are going to have to use these products not only at home but at the gym or at the office, too. Therefore, they need to buy one that’s more forgiving than convention eyeliners. With that firmly in our mind, we’ve assembled a guide which will help every woman achieve the perfect lined eye they want to achieve and without having to have the steady hand of a surgeon.

First, Choose the Right Eyeliner

The number of different eyeliner product currently available is almost mind-numbing. There are brush applicator liquid eyeliners, felt-tip applicators, cream eyeliners, gel eyeliners, pencil eyeliners, mechanical twist-up eyeliners, and several different eyeshadows that can also be used as an eyeliner. To make things really simple, we’re going to assume that a drugstore liquid eyeliner has been chosen from among the ten listed above. However, if you feel limited by the list, you should feel free to choose one that you like and that you feel comfortable applying.

Start With a Clean Slate

In order to get the most out of your eyeliner, you are going to have to treat your eyelids like a canvas. And much like you would with an artist’s canvas, you are going to have to take a few moments out of your day preparing your eyelids. This means that you are going to want to clean off any old makeup from your eyelids before you begin. Using your favorite makeup remover, make sure that you remove all traces of eye makeup. Once that’s been done, and your eyelids are clean and dry, then you are going to want to apply makeup in the following order: eyelid primer, eye-shadow, and then your eyeliner. When that’s been done, feel free to move on to the next step.

The Dot & Dash Method

Although there are several different ways to apply liquid eyeliner, many women like to use the dot and dash method. That’s because this method doesn’t require too steady of a hand and mistakes are a lot more forgiving. To use this technique, all you have to do is to draw dots and dashes along the lid to serve as a guide. Then all that really has to be done to connect the dots and dashes to make a solid line. That’s a whole lot easier than trying to draw one, uninterrupted line with your hand. If you’re going to use this technique, just be sure that you connect each individual dot or dash and don’t just try to draw a solid line through all of them.

Fix Your Lines & Add a Tail

Using a handheld mirror, a compact or your rearview mirror, check your eyeliner and make sure everything is smooth and all of your dots and dashes are connected. This can usually be done by just drawing along the edge of the liner to make sure its nice and smooth. If you want, you can also add a tail to your eyeliner, but that certainly isn’t necessary. Adding a tail, especially a long one, takes a little bit more skill than using eyeliner in the first place. Congratulations! You have now finished applying your liquid eyeliner.

Some Final Application Tips

Okay, now that we’ve gone through some of the basics of applying a drugstore liquid eyeliner, it’s time to cover some of the tips we may have missed in our steps. Below are some tips which will help you apply your eyeliner in an absolutely flawless manner.

  • Try to Use a Handheld Mirror or Compact—Trying to use your rear-view mirror or a bathroom mirror can make it difficult to see the eyeliner from all angles. Therefore, you should invest in a good compact or hand mirror so you can view the finished makeup application easily.
  • Apply as Close as Possible to Your Eyelashes—If there’s a gap between your eyeliner and your eyelashes, then it looks really sloppy and unprofessional. That’s why you should ensure that there aren’t any gaps. If this is difficult to do by hand, then consider using an eyeliner with a pencil-style applicator.
  • Don’t Draw Your Tails Downward—Some women draw their tails downward as a part of their individual style. Other women do this by accident. Unfortunately, this isn’t very creative and ends up making their eyes look droopy. To avoid a downward tail, apply a dot where you want the tail to swing upward and then connect that dot to the rest of the eyeliner to finish the effect.
  • Prevent Eyelid Transfer—If you eyeliner keeps transferring to your eyelid, then you may want to use a translucent powder to set it. This can help keep the eyeliner from smudging and from ending up on areas of the eyelid it doesn’t belong.
  • Avoid Thick Lines—Although some women believe that applying a thick eyeliner to their lid looks seductive and mysterious, which it does, it can also make the eyes appear smaller. And that’s not even mentioning the fact that a thick eyeliner always makes the lids look heavier than usual, too.
  • Don’t Make Your Tail Too Short—Although adding a tail to your eyeliner isn’t necessary, if you do decide to do it, then make sure it isn’t too short. A tail that’s too short looks like it’s either an eyeliner smudge or gets lost in the eye socket line. To avoid this, be sure to extend the tail past your eye’s crease for the best effect.
  • Avoid a Blunt Tail—Another thing to consider when adding a tail to your eyeliner line is to avoid a tail that’s too blunt. Blunt tails look blurry and quite messy, so avoid them whenever possible. If you’re having difficulty sharpening up your tail, then use a piece of tape as a guide.