Best Eyeliner Options For Your Gorgeous Eyes

woman put some make up - best eyeliner - artist

Image via Pixabay

With new brands and cosmetic lines emerging every day, the market is saturated with beauty products. It’s great to have so many choices, but trying to find a product that’s right for you can be overwhelming. Take a deep breath, makeup mavericks and mavens!

Discovering the best eyeliner just got easier. Through trial and error, we came up with a comprehensive list of the hottest products out there in our mission to find the best eyeliner for your collection.

In this review, we examined the ten best eyeliners. Product quality, benefits, and drawbacks were all considered within a broad range of pricing for every budget.

Product

Image

Our Rating

Price

Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner

stila

Image via Amazon

MAC Liquidlast Liner Wet Road

MAC

Image via Amazon

Xtreme Lashes Glideliner Long Lasting Eye Pencil

Xtreme Lashes GlideLiner Long Lasting Eye Pencil, Xtreme Black

Image via Amazon

Marc Jacobs Beauty Highliner Gel Eye Crayon Eyeliner

Marc Jacobs Beauty

Image via Amazon

Yves Saint Laurent Shocking Eyeliner

Yves Saint Laurent Shocking Eyeliner Effet Faux Cils Bold Felt Tip Eye...

Image via Amazon

Rimmel Soft Kohl Eyeliner Jet Black

Rimmel Soft Kohl Kajal Eyeliner, Jet Black 0.04 oz

Image via Amazon

LORAC Front of the Line Pro Eye Pencil

LORAC Front of the Line Pro Eye Pencil, Black

Image via Amazon

Christian Dior Diorshow Art Pen Eyeliner

Christian Dior Diorshow Art Pen Eyeliner for Women, No. 095 Noir...

Image via Amazon

Hourglass 1.5MM Mechanical Gel Eye Liner

Hourglass 1.5MM Mechanical Gel Eye Liner ~ Canyon ~

Image via Amazon

Trish McEvoy Lash Enhancing Liquid Liner Pen

Trish McEvoy Lash Enhancing Liquid Liner Pen 0.02oz (0.6ml)

Image via Amazon

How We Reviewed

In our tireless quest to find the best eyeliner, we had to make sure that each product reviewed either met or surpassed our criteria for a quality product. We looked at durability, cost, product quality, packaging, and versatility.

We also made it a point to review feedback from other beauty connoisseurs to confirm that our findings were closer to a universal experience for all makeup enthusiasts with discerning tastes.

Out of all liners we tested, the following ten brands offer the best eyeliner options in the market. 

Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner

Key Benefits

The Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner provides 24 hours of smudge free coverage. The micro-tip makes applying precise lines, thick or thin, a nearly effortless application.

Price

This product can be found on Amazon for an affordable price.

Pros

  • Great color selection  
  • Easy application
  • Rich pigment

Cons

  • Pen dries out quickly
  • Is not entirely waterproof
  • Prone to clumping

MAC Liquidlast Liner Wet Road

Key Benefits

MAC rarely lets us down and their luscious Liquidlast Liner is evidence of that. When we say this liner doesn’t smudge or smear, it really doesn’t.

Trying to take it off can be more difficult than putting it on if you don’t have a reliable eye makeup remover. MAC’s brand reputation makes blindly purchasing one of their products less of a gamble partly due because of their very generous return policy.

Price

MAC Liquidlast Liner can be found on Amazon for an affordable price.

Pros

  • Will not smudge, smear, or fade
  • Literally Waterproof 
  • Great selection of bold, rich colors
  • Brand reliability
  • Great Customer Service

Cons

  • Prone to clumping
  • Difficult to remove
  • Takes a while to dry

Xtreme Lashes Glideliner Long Lasting Eye Pencil

Xtreme Lashes GlideLiner Long Lasting Eye Pencil, Xtreme Black
  • Innovative long-lasting gel technology
  • Glides on easily and gently without tugging
  • Blends upon application, then dries into a smudge-proof finish

Key Benefits

Xtreme Lashes Glideliner claims to give the best of both worlds by combining the precision of a liquid liner with the softness of a pencil liner.

It was made to complement Xtreme’s line of eyelash extensions. Despite the claims of it being “long-lasting,” it comes off easily and quickly.

Price

Xtreme Lashes Glideliner Long Lasting Eye Pencil can be found on Amazon for an average market price.

Pros

  • Intense color 
  • Smooth application
  • Complementary to eyelash extensions

Cons

  • Smudges easily
  • Not waterproof
  • Requires sharpening often
  • High end price for a relatively low quality product

Marc Jacobs Beauty Highliner Gel Eye Crayon Eyeliner

Key Benefits

The second pencil to make our list is this gel liner from Marc Jacobs. For ingredient-conscious shoppers, this liner is free of phthalates, sulfates, and parabens.

This gel crayon is made with vitamin and rosehip seed oil, which is fantastic for protecting and moisturizing the delicate skin around the eyes. It goes on velvety smooth and is highly versatile in creating precise lines to smudges for smokey eye effects

Price

The Marc Jacobs Beauty Highliner Gel Eye Crayon can be found on Amazon for an average market price.

Pros

  • Waterproof
  • Accommodates a variety of looks
  • Smooth application
  • Gel liner needs no brush for application
  • Includes a sharpener
  • Comes in a wide range of colors with different finishes (glitter, matte, satin, and shimmer)

Cons

  • Can feel greasy
  • Gets stiff and more difficult to apply in colder climates
  • Smears when applying the tight lining technique at the water line

Yves Saint Laurent Shocking Eyeliner

Key Benefits

The legendary fashion house that has redefined style for decades also redefines your eyes. Dessin Du Regard Waterproof Liner by Yves Saint Laurent is the most expensive product we reviewed, but is it the best eyeliner on the market?

The application is smooth and velvety. The pigment is intense and highly resistant to smearing and smudging.

Price

The Yves Saint Laurent Dessin Du Regard Waterproof Long-Lasting Waterproof Eye Pencil can be found on Amazon for an expensive price

Pros

  • Bold pigment 
  • Glides like a liquid eyeliner
  • Includes a sharpener

Cons

  • Expensive
  • Easily comes off without makeup remover, not resistant, 
  • Not waterproof
  • Not contact lens friendly

Rimmel Soft Kohl

Rimmel Soft Kohl Kajal Eyeliner, Jet Black 0.04 oz
  • Soft, smudgeable colour kajal liner pencil

Key Benefits

On the other end of the price point spectrum, Rimmel’s Soft Kohl Eyeliner also made our list of exceptional liners.

It offers soft lines and a smooth application synonymous with kohl liners. This product won’t break your wallet and can be bought in most drugstore cosmetic aisles.

Price

The Rimmel Soft Kohl Eyeliner can be purchased on Amazon for a uniquely affordable price.

Pros

  • Affordable
  • Effective for tight lining
  • Intense pigment comparable to pricier competing brands
  • Smooth application

Cons

  • Wears off quickly
  • Smudges easily
  • Irritates contact lens wearers

LORAC Front of the Line Pro Eye Pencil

Key Benefits

LORAC’s Front of the Line Pro Eye Pencil is waterproof and comes in smooth, matte, and metallic finishes. Like most of the pencil liners reviewed, this product is effective in creating a variety of lines for different effects.

Price

The LORAC Front of the Line Pro Eye Pencil can be found on Amazon for an affordable price.

Pros

  • Safe for contact lens wearers
  • Comfortable for allergy sufferers
  • Rich pigment
  • Includes a built-in sharpener

Cons

  • Dries out quickly
  • Eyeliner falls out of the pencil
  • Black is not as saturated as the other colors

Christian Dior Diorshow Art Pen Eyeliner

Christian Dior Diorshow Art Pen Eyeliner for Women, No. 095 Noir...
  • A felt applicator calligrapher and texture gel-like, it provides an intense liA professional felt-tip eyelinerner sharp...
  • Renders a flawless & extraordinary graphic black line
  • Boasts a high-precision felt-tip applicator that provides either delicate or intense effect

Key Benefits

The Diorshow Art Pen by Christian Dior is a professional quality, liquid eyeliner with a felt-tip. It offers excellent control to create bold, sharp lines with ease.

Dior offers a high-quality beauty product at an affordable cost.

Price

The Christian Dior Diorshow Art Pen Eyeliner can be found on Amazon for an average market price.

Pros

  • Lasts all day   
  • Excellent handling for a flawless finish
  • Perfect for contact lens wearers and people with sensitive eyes
  • Brand reputation
  • Affordable

Cons

  • Application might be difficult for beginners
  • Dries out if not stored upside down
  • Jet Black color is not as dark as other liners

Hourglass 1.5MM Mechanical Gel Eye Liner

Hourglass 1.5MM Mechanical Gel Eye Liner ~ Canyon ~
  • Encapsulated in a 1.5MM mechanical pencil, this liner offers precision accuracy and ease of application. No pot, no...

Key Benefits

This thin, mechanical pencil offers all the benefits of using a gel liner without using a pot or brush. Hourglass definitely had tight lining in mind when creating this pencil. It has been tested by opthamologists and only requires two clicks to create lines.

Price

The Hourglass 1.5MM Mechanical Gel Eye Liner can be found on Amazon for an affordable price.

Pros

  • Convenient way to apply gel liner
  • Does not require sharpening
  • Great for tight lining
  • Color really stays all day

Cons

  • Runs out quickly
  • Gel eyeliner inside the pencil breaks easily
  • Some users might find it difficult to handle

Trish McEvoy Lash Enhancing Liquid Liner Pen

Trish McEvoy Lash Enhancing Liquid Liner Pen 0.02oz (0.6ml)
  • Liquid eyeliner defines eyes with controlled ease, while the clinically proven lash lengthing formula conditions and...

Key Benefits

Closing out our product review list is Trish McEvoy Lash Enhancing Liquid Liner Pen. It features an all-in-one formula that not only defines eyes but also conditions and enhances eyelashes.

It is water resistant and promises long-lasting wear, but is it the best eyeliner on the market?

Price

This Trish McEvoy Lash ENhancing Liquid Liner Pencil can be found on Amazon for an expensive price.

Pros

  • Conditions and enhances lashes  
  • Stays on all day

Cons

  • Expensive
  • Tip frays and creates inconsistent lines
  • Dries out quickly

Eyeliner FAQ

1. What is Eyeliner?

Eyeliner is a cosmetic used to define the contour of the eyes. This staple beauty product dates all the way back to Ancient Egypt. Some historians believe the Ancient Egyptians wore eyeliner to ward off evil spirits.

Others believe the Egyptians used eyeliner to deflect the harsh rays of the desert sun. Today, we use eyeliner to create a dramatic effect around the eyes.

2. What Are The Different Kinds of Eyeliner?

Eyeliner comes in different forms, in different colors, and each creates its own desired effect. For bold and precise lines, use a liquid liner. Powder-based eyeliner pencils create a softer, matte line and usually come in darker colors.

Wax-based eyeliner pencils are softer and can be applied quite easily. For smudgy eyes, kohl eyeliner soft powder base is perfect.

Available in dark matte shades, it is most often used in black to outline the eyes. Gel eyeliner gives the effect of a kohl pencil with the precision of a liquid liner.

3. How Is Eyeliner Applied?

Apply eyeliner along the contour of the eyelid near the eyelashes. There are different line styles to experiment with depending the on the mood a makeup artist is trying to achieve.

Tight lining is a technique where eyeliner is applied under the lashes of the upper lid and above the lashes of the lower lid. This technique makes eyelashes look longer.

4. Where Can You Purchase Eyeliner?

You can purchase eyeliner from pharmacies, department stores and specialty stores like Sephora. You can also purchase eyeliner online from sites like Amazon.

5. Who Should Wear Eyeliner?

Anyone who wants fierce definition around their eyes can wear eyeliner, but keep in mind that if you have certain allergies to cosmetic or skincare products, check the ingredients before using eyeliner.

The Verdict

woman with eyeliner

Image via Flickr

Depending on your individual skill level and requirements for the best eyeliner, four products stand out to us for different reasons.

For people confident in drawing precise lines, the Christian Dior Diorshow Art Pen is the best eyeliner out of all the liquid liners reviewed. It’s also the best eyeliner for contact lens wearers and people with sensitive eyes.

The affordable cost for such a professional instrument makes the Diorshow Art Pen a favorite.

For people new to experimenting with makeup, Rimmel Soft Kohl Eyeliner is our recommendation best eyeliner in pencil form out there. This brand is also excellent for seasoned makeup enthusiasts who are seeking a high-quality pencil at a low cost.

It’s very inexpensive which is great for those who do not want to invest too much money into an unfamiliar product. The Rimmel Soft Kohl Eyeliner Pencil leaves plenty of room for error correction, and the finish is just as bold as its pricier counterparts.

Overall, our vote for the best eyeliner in the beauty market is the Marc Jacobs Beauty Highliner Eye Crayon. What we love about this product is its versatility in creating lines and looks.

It mimics liquid liners beautifully and also creates soft lines for smokier effects. The added vitamin E and rosehip seed oil to the formula keeps the skin under the liner moisturized and protected.

Again, finding the perfect beauty products should address your individual needs to accommodate your unique beauty and style, so what's right for one might not be the best eyeliner for another.

This detailed review should make your journey to find the best eyeliner easier.