Top 10 Best Peanut Butters of 2019 – Reviews

Peanut butter is a common staple in just about everyone’s pantry, and there’s a good reason for that fact. Not only is peanut butter a food product that tastes great, but it’s also a food product that has a great nutritional profile. Nut butter is a good source of not only protein, but also fiber, vitamins, and minerals. And that’s more than enough of a reason to keep a jar of it in your cabinet at all times.

Thanks to the popularity of this product, there are now dozens of different peanut butter brands waiting to not only tantalize the taste buds of eager fans but also give them the nutrition they need. A large number of different brands can make it difficult for the average consumer to find one that is best for their family, so we went ahead and listed the ten brands that we feel are the best.

Best Peanut Butters – Top List

10Jif Cinnamon Spread

buy from amazon

Jif has decided that the best way to make peanut butter taste even better than it already does is by boosting its flavor with cinnamon, and that’s exactly what this product does. This gluten-free peanut spread still delivers the same 7-grams of protein per serving that any other spread delivers, but it does it with a little bit of flair. This product is ideal for making holiday cookies or for use in other foods where a great cinnamon taste is desired. It’s also pretty good when used to make PB&J sandwiches, especially when paired with an apple jam or a citrus jelly.

9Honey Peanut Butter by Justin’s

buy from amazon

Not only is this product a great tasting product that has a nice honey taste to it, but it’s also packed with the nutrition one expects from a quality peanut butter product. It has 7-grams of protein, 2-grams of fiber and contains zero trans-fats. It’s also made with care from a company that’s known for making a difference. This company sources its ingredients in a responsible way, helps to conserve the bees which make the honey and help to support not only Hunger Relief but also the Rainforest Alliance. And on top of all of that, it’s also a no-stir formula. This makes this product tasty, nutritious and socially responsible.

8Skippy Natural Creamy

buy from amazon

This Skippy product is designed to be an all natural peanut butter that does away with some of the inferior ingredients that other nut butter products use in their formulation. In fact, it only contains four ingredients: roasted peanuts, sugar, palm oil and salt. And that’s all that’s in it. This product is also a great source of Vitamin E and has zero trans fats per serving. And it’s a product that has won several awards for being the best tasting natural peanut butter. When all of this is factored together, it’s easy to see why this product is beginning to gain quite a following among peanut spread fans.

7Picot Productions Pic’s Crunchy

buy from amazon

Not only is Pic’s Crunchy a great product, but it’s also a bit of an unusual one. It’s made with nothing but Australian sourced peanuts which are known for their high oleic content. This means that it’s high in monounsaturated fats, which makes it heart healthy like olive oil. It’s also a great tasting product, but it does require stirring to keep the oils from floating on top of it. Fortunately, this company has worked to make this easier to do by making their jar short and stout, so it’s quite easy to get a knife down to the bottom of it to give it a good stir.

6Teddie All Natural Super Chunky

buy from amazon

This old-fashioned style peanut butter is manufactured by a company who has been making peanut spreads and butter products for over 92-years. And in all of that time, they’ve never had to recall one of their products, which by itself is a testament to their quality control standards. Having said that, it’s also worth mentioning that this product also tastes great and is true peanut butter and not a spread. It’s proudly made in the United States using nothing but American sourced peanuts and is not only GMO-free but is also vegan-friendly and gluten-free as well.

5Peanut Butter & Co. Smooth Operator

buy from amazon

Whether this product is placed on crackers, used in PB&J sandwiches or whipped into an amazing vegan milkshake, it’s sure to provide the taste and the quality consumers expect out of their peanut spread. It’s only made with a small handful of ingredients and doesn’t contain many of the chemicals that some other peanut butter products do. It’s only made with roasted peanuts, dried cane syrup, palm fruit oil, and a little bit of salt. These four ingredients make a tasty spread that doesn’t separate from its oil like other products do, and contain 7-grams of protein per serving. It’s also a vegan, Kosher, GMO-free and gluten-free product, too.

4Peter Pan Creamy

buy from amazon

Peter Pan is a brand that’s been creating high-quality peanut butter products that people love, and after tasting this product, it’s easy to see why they’re so loved. It’s because they use an interesting blend of peanuts that creates a spread that’s smooth and creamy and tastes exactly as it should taste. This product isn’t made with high-fructose corn syrup and delivers 7-grams of protein in each serving. This makes this an ideal spread for making cookies, smoothies and of course, PB&J sandwiches. It’s also a peanut spread that’s sure to put a smile on just about any child’s face.

3Home Plate All Natural Creamy

buy from amazon

Home Plate has been a company that’s been producing great peanut butter for quite some time now. It’s a company that was originally founded by professional baseball players who wanted to capture that iconic American peanut spread taste that they remember so fondly from their childhoods. And in our opinion, they did a pretty good job at capturing that vibe. This product never needs to be stirred, and never gets chalky or has a gritty taste to it. It’s also packed with 7-grams of high-quality protein that makes it a great post-workout snack, or can be used to make healthy smoothies or protein shakes.

2Bell Plantation Powdered PB2 Bundle

buy from amazon

This amazing bundle features a one pound jar of traditional PB2 peanut butter and a one-pound jar of their chocolate flavored formula. Each of these products contains no artificial flavors, preservatives or sweeteners and is in a powdered form, so it doesn’t contain all of the fat that other peanut spreads have in their formulations. In fact, it contains approximately 85% fewer calories and fat than traditional products contain. And since this product is in powder form, it has an extremely long shelf life. It can also be reconstituted quite easily into butter form and is easy to use for baking.

1Jif Creamy Peanut Butter Twin Pack

buy from amazon

This two pack of 40-ounce peanut butter jars are manufactured by a company that’s been making quality peanut spreads for approximately 60+ years now. And all of that time has taught them how to make a product that not only delivers a great punch of protein but also taste great, too. This smooth and creamy blend delivers 7-grams of protein per serving and contains no artificial preservatives. It’s easy-to-use, never needs to be stirred and is great for everything from making sandwiches to baking. And it’s only made with high-quality peanuts, so consumers can rest assured of its quality. And that’s why this is the best peanut butter currently available.

Can’t Find What You’re Looking For? Check these suggestions:

A Basic Peanut Butter Guide

Just about everyone knows or thinks they know, what to do with a peanut. The vast majority of people make it into PB&J sandwiches or make peanut butter cookies out of them, and both of those things are good uses for this product. However, those aren’t the only two things that this product can be used for in the kitchen. In fact, this product has quite a few uses that are pretty impressive, if a person wants to take the time to learn about them. Before we begin with some of the marvelous things that can be done with this product, we’d like to take a few moments and talk about the history of this product first.

The History of Peanut Butter

Although several South American native populations roasted peanuts and then used their stone tools to grind them into a paste, and did so for hundreds of years, the first modern incarnation of peanut butter wasn’t actually invented until 1884. This is the year when Marcellus Gilmore Edson invented a peanut paste by milling roasted peanuts between two heated plates. Later on, Dr. John Harvey Kellogg would then go on to patent an actual peanut butter making process in 1895.

Even though the manufacturing process allowed nut butter to maintain consistent quality levels, what really revolutionized the process was the creation of the first machine that could create peanut butter.  This machine was invented by Dr. Ambrose Straub in 1903 in St. Louis, Mo. However, no conversation about this product would be complete without mentioning one of the great advocates for peanut butter and the person who helped establish it as a nutritious dietary staple: George Washington Carver. His work is primarily the reason why over 93% of all Americans use this product today.

Top Peanut Butter Uses

As promised, we’ve come up with a number of different uses for this product. Although not everyone will want to follow all of these uses, there’s bound to be some that will tickle any peanut butter fan’s fancy. With that being said, here are our top uses for peanut butter.

  • Shaving Cream: Yes, peanut butter can not only be used as shaving cream in a pinch, but it actually makes a pretty good one. That’s because the oils in it help to prevent the razor from nicking the face and the peanut oil helps to moisturize the skin.
  • WD-40 Replacement: This product can also be used to lubricate squeaking door hinges or hard to close drawers. Once again, that’s because of the oils which can be found in the butter. These oils lubricate very well.
  • Wood Scratch Remover: If you have a scratch in your wood banister or wallboard, then peanut butter can be used to fix it. Simply rub it on the scratch, wait for approximately 40-minutes and then wipe it away. The scratch will then be incredibly hard to see.
  • Hair Moisturizer: A lot of people already know this trick, but it’s still worth mentioning. Rubbing peanut butter on your scalp and leaving it on for a few minutes before washing the hair can result in fuller and more moisturized hair follicles.
  • Pest Bait: If you have ants, mice or roaches, then peanut butter can be used to eliminate them. It can be used to bait mousetraps. It can also be used to make ant poison by mixing 2-teaspoons of peanut butter with a teaspoon of borax and a 1/2-teaspoon of baking soda. And finally, if a near-empty peanut butter jar is left on the floor, roaches will crawl into it and become stuck in the peanut butter. It’s then just a matter of replacing the lid and throwing the jar away.
  • Make Inexpensive Bird Feeders: All you have to do is coat pine cones with peanut butter and then roll them in bird seed. When that’s done, hang them in an area accessible by birds. Birds absolutely love these inexpensive bird feeders.
  • Make a Child’s Snack: Peanut butter can be placed inside celery sticks with raisins on top. This creates an iconic child’s snack known as “Ants on a Log.”
  • Make a Quick Milkshake: Don’t have a lot of time? Well, if you don’t, then you can create a super fast malted milkshake. A 1/2-cup of milk, 2-Tablespoons of peanut butter, 3-Tablespoons of malted milk powder, 2-cups of vanilla ice cream and 2 bananas can be added to a blender and turned into a great milkshake.
  • Make Vegan Ice Cream: 2 frozen bananas, 2-Tablespoons of peanut butter and jelly can be added into a food processor and turned into vegan ice cream.