Top 10 Best Drugstore Eyeshadows of 2019 – Reviews

Walking into a local pharmacy or convenience store to buy an inexpensive eyeshadow can be somewhat of a risky process. It can be difficult to buy the exact colors that you need or the right brand. Buying online makes for a more streamlined process, but it comes with an exact opposite set of problems. Consumers have to search through dozens of different products to find the right one. Hopefully, we can fix this problem and make the process a little bit better.

We have researched all of the major brands and have come up with a list of the best drugstore eyeshadow products currently available. Although the consumer will still have to choose the right one for their eye color and style, we still feel the following selection provides a good starting point for most people to find a shade that really suits them well.

Best Drugstore Eyeshadows Of 2019

10Covergirl Eye Enhancers Silver Lining

buy from amazon

Consumers who have used Covergirl products in the past will not only notice the redesigned package of this product but will also notice that the formula has been improved, too. This collection is a glittery silver eyeshadow that’s formulated to be easy to use, last for hours. It’s a silver color that will really make blue and green eyes pop, but can easily be used on any color eyes. Whether the wearer is looking for a bright way to highlight their eyes or want to add a little bit of sophistication to their look, this product is ready to comply with their wishes.

9L’Oreal Paris Studio Secrets Sand Dune Professional Duos

buy from amazon

This eyeshadow was crafted by L’Oréal makeup artists to create two different colors that work in unison to bring something extremely special to just about anyone’s eyes. This formula is made in Paris and is silk-smooth, so it goes on easily and is always easy to blend. This color coordinated palate, which the company has aptly named Sand Dune, features two different Earth tones which can be used in any combination the wearer chooses. It also comes with an easy-to-use applicator brush that allows the wearer to apply their eyeshadow quickly and almost effortlessly. Anyone looking to explore a more mysterious side of their personality may want to give this eyeshadow a try.

8Maybelline New York Expert Wear Sunbaked Neutrals

buy from amazon

This eyeshadow formula has not only been ophthalmologist tested and proven to be safe for sensitive eyes, but it also comes in a fade-proof formula that never creases and goes on smoothly. This product features 8 different colors which have been coordinated by beauty experts to work together flawlessly. These colors come in three distinct types which include matte colors, shimmer, and high-pearl eyeshadows as well. This makes this combination of colors very versatile and capable of being used for any social function. Whether you need something that goes with your evening wear or something suitable for the office, this collection has you covered.

7L’Oréal Paris Makeup Infallible 24HR Shadow

buy from amazon

This 24-hour formula is not only designed to be waterproof, but it’s also designed to be virtually fade and crease resistant as well. It’s has a creamy, powdery texture that feels luxurious and goes on extremely smoothly. It features an intense, sparkling Amber color which goes well on cooler skin tones but can be used with virtually any color of eyes. This product is a perfect way for people to draw attention to their eyes and inject a little bit of fun into their life. Although this isn’t a drugstore eyeshadow that’s suitable for everyone, it does perform well and delivers high-pigment color.

6Maybelline N.Y. EyeStudio Lawless Lavender

buy from amazon

This marbelized eyeshadow is somewhat of a difficult product to explain because it has so much going for it, but we’ll give it a try. This formula uses 7-different pigments which are swirled together to make a luminescent product that’s unlike most of the other eyeshadows available, including some of the more expensive brands. Although it doesn’t have the staying power of some other brands, it does produce an amazing look that really has to be seen to be appreciated. Saying that this product is unique is somewhat of an understatement. It’s a color that really pops and is pretty unique.

5Revlon Luxurious Color Diamond Starry Pink

buy from amazon

If a diamond luster is something that you’re searching for, then this product is sure to provide the shine that you’ve been wanting. It has a muted metallic color that really pops when it’s applied. This formula is called Starry Pink, and it’s glittery luminescence really catches the light in ways that other eyeshadow products simply fail to do. This product goes on smoothly, doesn’t fade and produces a rich color that lasts all day long. Regardless of whether the wearer is heading out for a night on the town or is heading to the beach, this eyeshadow is ready to stun everyone who sees it.

4L.A. Girl Eyeshadow Nudes

buy from amazon

It’s quite easy to inject a little bit of West Coast attitude into any makeup collection when this collection of L.A. Girl Nudes is added to it. This product comes in a case that comes with a double-side eyeshadow applicator and a mirror, so applying the product is quick and easy no matter where you are. This product also features a selection of nude pigments which will help the user blend that perfect smokey eye or shade their eyelids for a night out on the town. All of the colors in this collection are easy to blend and produce fantastic results that last all day or all night long.

3Covergirl Intense Shadowblast Platinum Pop

buy from amazon

Starting your day having to add a primer before you add your eyeshadow can be a real pain, but fortunately, this product doesn’t require a primer because it has one built into its formula. That not only makes application of this eyeshadow a snap, but it also produces a crease-proof color that’s capable of lasting all day long. This formula is also waterproof, so no matter what you’re doing you can be confident that your eyeshadow is going to stay where it belongs. And since this product has a steel-like color to it, it’s sure to bring a lot of attention when it’s worn.

2L’Oreal Paris HiP Studio Secrets Metallic Shadow Duos

buy from amazon

If there’s one thing that can be said about this product, it’s that it does produce professional results. This metallic eyeshadow is shimmery, glides on smoothly and produces a look that’s nothing short of glamorous. It’s also easy-to-apply and produces a color that lasts for hours on end. Some metallic eyeshadows end up leaving flakes of metal all over the place, but this one is different because it stays right where it belongs. So it doesn’t matter if the wearer is walking the red carpet or is heading out for an evening out, this glittery eyeshadow is going to grab and hold everyone’s attention.

1Lamora Best Pro 16-Color Eyeshadow Palette

buy from amazon

This collection of 16 vibrant colors gives the user a number of options when they’re putting on their makeup for the day. It also gives the wearer plenty of different styles they can play with to achieve a look that’s suitable for either work, play, or even for a night out on the town. In its travel-friendly case are 16 colors that can be divided into several different eyeshadow types useful for any occasion. Some of the eyeshadow colors which can be found in this exciting collection include mauve, pearl, cream, comfort, rust, bronze, wood, espresso, plum, satin, and metal. Beautiful metallic colors and sensual nude shades all come together in this exciting collection of eyeshadows.

Can’t Find What You’re Looking For? Check these suggestions:

Choosing the Right Drugstore Eyeshadow

Now that we’ve narrowed a selection of products down to the best drugstore eyeshadows available, it’s time to talk about how to choose the right one for you. Since each and every person has different needs when it comes to makeup, it’s important to choose one that suits you personally. Although a product might be rated as the number one product by a group of people, it doesn’t mean that it is going to suit your style or that you are even going to like it. Therefore, it’s important to seriously consider what you want to get out of your eyeshadow and which one might be best for you.

In our estimation, there are probably two different ways to choose an eyeshadow. A person can buy one according to skin tone or eye color. That’s why we’ve decided to give a breakdown of each of these selection methods, so our readers have a few ways to go about selecting their favorite types of eyeshadow.

Method One: Choosing Eyeshadow by Skin Tone

Before you can use this method to buy your eyeshadow, you first have to figure out your personal skin tone. A method often recommended by many experts for determining skin tone is by looking at your veins in natural lighting. If you can’t determine the color of your veins in natural light, then you either have a darker complexion or a neutral skin tone. If that’s the case, then you can either have a warm or cool skin tone. On the other hand, if your veins appear green, then most likely you have a warm skin tone. And finally, if your veins appear either purple or with a blueish tint, then you probably have a cool skin tone.

If you can’t determine whether you have a warm or a cool skin tone, then ask yourself whether you look better in silver or look better in gold. If you look better in gold, then you’re probably a warm skin tone. If you look better in silver, then you’re probably a cool skin tone. And finally, if you look good in either gold or silver, then you probably have a neutral skin tone.

If you have a cool skin tone, then you may want to try eyeshadow colors in the blue, pink, silver, lilac, or gray. If you have a warm skin tone, then you may want to try eyeshadow colors in coral, bronze, light green, or even light pink. When it comes to neutral skin tones, they have a little more flexibility as far as color is concerned. People with a neutral skin tone can wear just about anything, so if you have a neutral skin tone you may want to experiment with different colors before deciding on your favorite. One color we would recommend for neutral skin tones, however, is a natural or nude palette.

Method Two: Choosing Eyeshadow by Eye Color

Choosing a drugstore eyeshadow according to eye color is a little bit easier than choosing it by skin tone. Below are some of the more common eye colors and the shades that go well with them. Although these combinations aren’t written in stone, they’re a good first step in choosing a color that’s right for you.

  • Blue Eyes: Individuals with blue eyes should choose a light shade eyeshadow to enhance their eye color. Colors that work well for blue-eyed people include champagne or coral.
  • Green Eyes: Green eyes tend to stand out on their own, so it’s important to choose a softer eyeshadow like a light pink or plum.
  • Brown Eyes: When it comes to eyeshadow colors, brown eyes are the most versatile. Although light brown eyes would do best with sticking to light pinks or reddish colored browns, dark brown eyes can pull almost any color off.
  • Hazel Eyes: To maintain the color shade of hazel eyes, it’s important to choose gold or pink eyeshadow. However, experimenting with different shades can produce some interesting results, so it’s best to try out a few different colors before deciding on just one.
  • Grey Eyes: For best results, use smokey or metallic colors. Blues and greens also look good on grey eyes.
  • Of course, if you want you can also choose your eyeshadow according to your hair color. If you choose your eyeshadow according to hair color, then be sure to choose neutral colors for blonde hair, muted colors for red hair, and lighter shades for use with grey hair. If you have brown hair, then you can experiment to find out which works best for you because almost every color will go with brown hair.